A software tool meant to help reduce emergency hospital admissions is of limited use and benefit to patients, a new study of GPs’ views and experiences has revealed.
The study builds on earlier research by the same team showing that emergency admissions had gone up – not down – when the tool was introduced in Wales, which led to its rollout being halted, though it continues to be used widely in England, Scotland and Northern Ireland.
Researchers say the new study reinforces the need for more evidence and research on the implementation of the software and its effects.
The software is a risk prediction tool, which in Wales is called PRISM. It identifies people who are most at risk of needing emergency care, based on past use of healthcare, diagnoses and medications. The thinking is that targeted management of these patients can reduce emergency admissions to hospital, improve patient outcomes and experience, and provide better value for money.
However, researchers at Swansea University Medical School, who evaluated the use of PRISM in Wales, found that there is little evidence to suggest that it meets these objectives.
Now, to shed more light on how the tool is used in practice, the same team have published a second study, exploring the views and experiences of GPs and practice managers who used PRISM.
They interviewed 22 GPs and practice managers in 18 practices in south Wales, between three and six months after they began using PRISM and then again 18 months later.
They found that GPs generally judged it unlikely that PRISM had any effect on emergency admissions, with a widespread feeling that admissions initiated by GPs were already low with little scope for further reductions
Respondents reported the decision to use PRISM was based mainly on wanting to secure incentives offered by the Welsh Government under its Quality and Outcome Framework for improving care.
The survey also found that the use of PRISM was inhibited by it not being integrated with practice systems and most doubted any large-scale impact from PRISM, but cited examples of impact on individual patient care.
The majority of respondents reported that PRISM had made them more aware of high-risk patients, flagging up some patients who had not previously been considered to be in the high-risk category.
The researchers’ overall conclusions were that views of PRISM in general practice were mixed, and that policymakers need more information about how these tools are used in practice, and the effects of these tools on decision-making as well as patient outcomes.
Professor Helen Snooks from the project team at Swansea University Medical School said: “Tools like PRISM are used widely by the NHS in primary and community care, with the aim of reducing emergency hospital admissions. However, there is a lack of evidence to support the view that they enable proactive care and improve patient outcomes.
“Our research highlighted very mixed views and experiences among GPs and practice managers about use of PRISM. This was often short-term and driven by external factors rather than embedded in new ways of working.
“Decision-makers need more information about the implementation and effects of such tools in primary and community settings to inform future policy on their use.
Given the current context of rising emergency admissions, and Department of Health incentives in England to use these risk tools in community services, our findings are important and timely.”
(Lead image: Swansea University)
HSBC to shut Port Talbot and Tenby bank branches in latest round of closures
Rob Page: ‘We must now look to the future’
Port Talbot grandfather jailed for running massive cannabis ring
BHF funding offers hope for inherited cardiac conditions patients
Sarah Millican is bringing her latest comedy tour to Swansea
Pembrokeshire CBD Centre becomes UK’s first High Street CBD store partnered with medical cannabis clinic
Llanmoor Homes secures planning for 280 acre new ‘Pentref Rhostir’ community near Llangyfelach
Court grants police further extension to question three people on Bridgend baby deaths
Inspirational sporting achievements recognised in Pembrokeshire awards
New survey reveals money-draining culprit affects more than 50% of British households
Free bus travel returns to Swansea for Christmas
Date set for Llanelli Christmas Carnival and lights switch-on
Street pianos to bring music and colour to Swansea’s streets
Four Pembrokeshire women to take on ‘world’s toughest row’
UWTSD to host Cerebra families during Swansea Christmas Parade
Brynhyfryd pub gets brand new look in time to celebrate World Cup
Gavin & Stacey star Ruth Jones says getting honorary doctorate from Open University was ‘tidy, lush and crackin’
Swansea set to host football World Cup Fan Park
Swansea Christmas Parade: What you need to know for this Sunday’s event
New video teaches people how to sing ‘Yma o Hyd’ – with a bitesize history of Wales and the Welsh language
Pontardawe2 days ago
Pontardawe Swimming Pool to close due to structural issues
Business6 days ago
Carmarthenshire logistics company celebrates 50th anniversary by holding a family fun day in aid of Wales Air Ambulance
Swansea2 days ago
Swansea’s Skyline project moves a step closer with site investigation
Photography7 days ago
Swansea man wins Historic Photographer of the Year competition
Education6 days ago
FIVE new schools could be coming to Neath Port Talbot
Business7 days ago
International consortium on board to deliver Swansea renewable energy project
Swansea7 days ago
Swansea now third busiest train station in Wales – but overall ridership down on pre-pandemic levels
Food & Drink6 days ago
World Cup fans are swapping traditional burgers and sausages for Christmas party food as they stock up for the tournament