Cutting Wales from four professional rugby teams to three would save the Welsh Rugby Union £6m a year, against the £18.1m it lost last year.
That is the sum at the centre of new findings from the report the Ospreys commissioned from Sheffield Hallam University, released by the club today.
Its authors conclude that the cut “would not address the deficit the WRU accrued in 2024, 2025 or 2026”.
The Ospreys and the Scarlets are competing for a single licence in the west from 2028-29, and the union is due to name its choice by the end of June 2027.
The club released the report’s first findings last week, on derbies, crowds and players. Ospreys director Roger Blyth said it had since been suggested that the report “was silent on money”.
He said: “It is not. Sheffield Hallam have taken the Union’s own accounts and the Union’s own funding figures, and the arithmetic is there for anyone to read: a £6m saving against an £18.1m loss.”
Record WRU turnover of £116.2m, and a loss in four years out of five
The researchers worked from the union’s filed accounts. Turnover reached £116.2m in the year to June 2026, the fifth record in a row, the report says.
Income has grown by £21.9m since 2022, yet the union made a pre-tax loss in four of those five years.
The £6m comes from the WRU’s own funding plans. Four clubs at £6.5m each cost £26m.
Three at £6.7m would cost £20m, leaving each surviving club about £200,000 better off.
Dr Steve Bullough, the report’s lead author, said: “Turnover has reached a record level in each of those years, yet a loss was recorded in four of them. On those figures, a £6m saving would not address the deficit.”
The report also points to Ireland, where the IRFU funds four provinces on an income of €98m, about £82m, in 2025.
It looks at Wales home games too. Seven internationals in 2025-26 drew 95,562 more people than five the season before and brought in £2m more, while the average crowd fell from 66,523 to 61,168.
Six Welsh derbies a season instead of 12
Games between the four Welsh clubs produced 48% of league crowds in Wales between 2012 and 2026, the report says. With three clubs there would be six a season, down from 12.
Dr Bullough said almost half of the WRU’s income comes from the men’s national team, and that shrinking the club game was unlikely to improve it.
He said: “Removing a club would mean fewer Welsh supporters attending professional matches and fewer elite playing opportunities in Wales, and that is not likely to raise interest in the national team.”
The report does not put a figure on what fewer derbies would cost in ticket, hospitality and sponsorship income. Dr Bullough said that would need a full economic impact assessment, “which we have not seen”.
What the report leaves out, and the WRU’s case for three teams
The Ospreys commissioned and paid for the report. The club says the fee was fixed in advance and the conclusions are the authors’ own.
Its authors say it uses a limited set of financial measures. A full comparison of the clubs’ financial health would need all four sets of accounts and data on how far each depends on its backers, they say.
The WRU has said it needs to cut what it spends on professional rugby from £26m to £20m by 2028. The Keystone report it used to back the plan put the Ospreys’ revenue lowest of the four.
The Sheffield Hallam team said Keystone ranks the clubs on revenue while noting that all four made losses. Revenue alone “is not a sufficient measure of financial sustainability”, they said.
Blyth called the decision “a choice about how money is allocated by our governing body”.
He added: “This is not about one club against another. We want four clubs, and we want Cardiff, Dragons and Scarlets alongside us.”
Blyth said: “Everyone in Welsh rugby wants a game that pays its way. The question the report asks is whether taking a club away gets us there, and what it costs in derbies, crowds and players.”
Managing director Richard Lancaster said the move to St Helen’s was already paying off, with sponsorship “stronger than ever” and demand for corporate hospitality ahead of budget.
The club hosts Leinster, Harlequins and the Scarlets there in December.
The full report goes to the WRU next week, and the Ospreys say it will be published at the end of November. New WRU chair Lyndon Faulkner is reviewing the plan to cut a team.
Discover more from Swansea Bay News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
