Seven in ten people who answered Hywel Dda University Health Board’s stroke consultation disagreed with its plan to care for west Wales stroke patients in one specialist unit in Carmarthen, the health board says.
Under the plan, Prince Philip Hospital would become a “treat and transfer” hospital. Stroke patients from Llanelli would still be taken there to be assessed, then moved to Glangwili for their stay on the ward.
The health board has now published what people told it, ten days before its board decides on Thursday, 26 November. It says no decision has been made.
434 people strongly disagreed with the Glangwili plan
Of the 745 people who answered the question, 434 strongly disagreed that the plan would improve clinical standards, patient safety and staff shortages, and another 83 tended to disagree, the health board says. Just 176 agreed.
Asked whether one of the options the board had looked at before would work better, half picked “none of these”, the health board says.
More than 3,000 people took part in the eight weeks to 26 July, the health board says, through 751 questionnaires and more than 120 events, meetings and online sessions.
Carmarthenshire more likely to back it, but Llanelli pushed back
People in Carmarthenshire were more likely than anyone to agree with the plan, according to the health board. Opposition was strongest in Ceredigion, Pembrokeshire, Powys and south Gwynedd.
Carmarthenshire was also under-represented. Only 143 of the 719 questionnaires that gave a postcode came from the county, about one in five, though around half the people the health board serves live there.
The Llanelli drop-in at the Selwyn Samuel Centre in June was a different story. The health board recorded “significant resistance” there, with people praising the care they had received at Prince Philip and asking why a service that worked had to change.
One person told the health board: “The stroke unit in Prince Philip Hospital was excellent.” Another said: “Lack of ambulances is a deep concern.”
Some at the Llanelli event doubted their views would change anything. One said: “I want the Board to listen and come up with a fair decision not a political decision.”
Llanelli Town Council, which wants Prince Philip’s stroke unit built up rather than scaled back, told the health board that residents were raising with councillors that “they are losing access to stroke services”.
Campaign group SOSPPAN suggested patients needing more than 12 days’ care should go back to their “home hospital” so their families could help them recover.
‘It’s not sustainable’: staff on Prince Philip’s stroke ward
Not everyone at Prince Philip was against change. Staff on Ward 9, the hospital’s stroke ward, were among those who said the current set-up could not last.
One told the consultation: “Can’t carry on with 4 stroke units. It’s not sustainable.”
Swansea Bay University Health Board, which runs Morriston Hospital, told the consultation it backed the plan as part of a wider move towards a regional stroke service. It also warned it was “struggling to appoint 24/7 stroke consultant cover” itself, and expected Hywel Dda would struggle too.
Why the health board wants one 24-hour unit at Glangwili
Stroke care is currently split between Bronglais, Glangwili, Prince Philip and Withybush. The health board says none of them consistently meets national clinical standards, and there is no specialist cover 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
Lee Davies, its executive director of strategy and planning, said: “We recognise the strength of feeling and interest in these proposals, and I would like to reassure people that no decision has been made.”
He added: “Whichever option is chosen, the initial assessment and treatment of a suspected stroke would remain unchanged. The proposals focus on the specialist stroke care that follows.”
Ruth Evans, from Narberth, told the consultation that her 90-year-old mother had three mini strokes in a week. On a weekday at Withybush they saw the stroke specialist and the care was “amazing”, she said, but on the Saturday it was “completely different”.
What happens next
The board papers, and a link to watch the meeting live, go online on Friday, 20 November. If change is approved, it will be phased in, the health board said when the consultation closed in July.
Anyone with a suspected stroke should still call 999 and will still go to their nearest suitable hospital first. Patients who need a clot removed by thrombectomy will continue to go to Bristol or Cardiff.
Discover more from Swansea Bay News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
