SWANSEA: 25 of 27 children’s homes ‘could close’ over profit ban

The firms that run them say they won’t change. Ministers say the money should be spent on children.

Kit Peters
7 Min Read
A young person in a T-shirt and jeans sits on a staircase, head in hand, looking at a phone
A young person sits alone on a staircaseStock image

Swansea could lose all but two of its children’s homes, the body that represents their operators has warned.

Twenty-five of the city’s 27 homes are run for profit, and from April 2030 councils will be banned from placing new children in them.

The Children’s Homes Association says the firms behind them have told it they will not turn themselves into not-for-profits to carry on.

Its chief executive, Dr Mark Kerr, said: “We know from the organisations operating these children’s homes that they are not going to change their structures to meet the Welsh Government’s rules. This is not a hypothetical risk.”

Between them, the 25 homes have 92 of Swansea’s 96 registered places, Welsh Government figures for the end of March show.

The other two homes are Swansea Council’s own, with four places.

Three or four children and a round-the-clock team: what a children’s home is for

A children’s home is where a child in care lives when they cannot stay with their own family, and a foster home is not right for them or cannot be found.

They are small. Swansea’s 27 homes have 96 places between them, fewer than four children to a home on average.

Staff work in shifts, so there is an adult there day and night.

Most children in care never live in one.

Of the 473 children Swansea Council was looking after at the end of March, 58 were in residential placements last year, twice as many as five years before. Most of the rest live with foster carers or relatives.

Those who do go into a home tend to have the most complex needs, the association says: children who have lived through trauma, abuse or neglect, or been moved again and again.

The council that placed a child stays responsible for them, and Care Inspectorate Wales regulates and inspects the homes.

“Not simply businesses”: the children these homes were built around

Some of Swansea’s homes were set up with councils around one particular child whose needs could not be met anywhere else, Dr Kerr said.

He added: “You cannot simply replace that expertise by buying another building and recruiting a new team.”

Homes barred from taking new children would become “financially unsustainable” as the children living there moved on, he warned. “We expect closures to follow,” he said.

He said: “These are children’s homes, not simply businesses.”

The fear, the association says, is more children living away from their families, schools and communities.

Why Wales is taking the profit out of children’s homes

The ban comes from a law passed under the last Welsh Government, which wants money for children in care spent on their care.

The government elected in May is carrying on with it. Delyth Jewell, the Deputy Minister for Social Care, Mental Health and Women’s Health, told the Senedd in July that it remained committed to removing profit from the care of looked-after children.

Its explanation is that with profit-making firms, “public money can end up in shareholders’ pockets”.

No new for-profit home has been able to register in Wales since April, and existing ones cannot add places.

Homes can stay in business by becoming a charitable company or another approved not-for-profit, and ministers are paying for free help to make the switch.

The 2030 ban covers new placements.

The deadline has already been moved once. Ministers first aimed to end profit in children’s care by 2027, and pushed that back three years after warnings about disruption to children’s care.

The operators are not alone in their doubts. The Welsh Local Government Association backed the aim of the law as it went through the Senedd, but warned it risked piling pressure on a care system that was already stretched.

Across Wales, 1,069 of 1,349 children’s home places are in for-profit homes, which is 79%.

£17.5m to replace Swansea’s 25 homes, campaign claims

Replacing all 25 would cost about £17.5m before a single member of staff was hired, according to Care Children Need, the campaign the association runs with funding from care providers.

It gets there by taking £700,000, the sum it says ministers allow for setting up one new home, 25 times over. It calls the total an illustration, not a forecast.

Not all of it would fall on Swansea, because homes here also take children placed by other councils.

Dr Kerr said: “Nobody disputes that money intended for vulnerable children should benefit those children. But we need to ask a very simple question: how does making it harder to keep existing children’s homes open help the children who depend on them?”

The campaign wants ministers to push back the 2030 deadline, review the policy and find a way for existing homes to stay open.

Council officers told councillors in July that new local residential provision was part of their plan for children in care.

Author

Kit Peters

Kit Peters is a journalist and the editor of Swansea Bay News, covering Swansea, Neath Port Talbot and Carmarthenshire since 2020.


Discover more from Swansea Bay News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share This Article
Follow:
Kit Peters is a journalist and the editor of Swansea Bay News, covering Swansea, Neath Port Talbot and Carmarthenshire since 2020.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply