The Welsh Rugby Union board has refused to stand down, and confirmed that cutting Wales to three professional clubs is settled.
In a statement issued on Saturday morning, all 11 board members said there was no justification for the personal insults and attacks aimed at WRU staff and directors.
For the Ospreys and Scarlets, still contesting the last west Wales licence, the significant word is buried in the middle: the board says it has affirmed the three-club decision.
The statement follows a week of open revolt. Hayley Parsons, the former Cardiff director, told WalesOnline on Thursday that the board should resign, saying it lacked rugby and commercial expertise and had made things worse over three years.
Wales dual-code great Jonathan Davies backed her the following day and called for an interim board to steady the game. “This board has been in place for three years and it’s failed to deliver,” he said.
Rob Regan, a former Principality chief operating officer, has since put himself forward to sit on an alternative interim board, arguing the current regime has to go.
The board’s answer is that it will listen, but not to complaints alone. It says it welcomes constructive input and is not deaf to criticism, but that criticism has to come with credible alternatives.
It also defends its own make-up, pointing out that the changes creating the current board were voted through almost unanimously by member clubs, and were designed to bring in commercial, financial and professional rugby expertise.
On the substance, the board restated the money. There is no realistic prospect, it says, of Welsh rugby raising enough revenue to fund four professional teams competitively beyond 2028.
Both the available finances and the pool of players, the statement argues, are spread too thinly across four clubs to give any of them what they need.
The board says it reconsidered a range of factors before settling the question again, among them population and accessibility, rugby infrastructure, financial sustainability, player pathways, sporting performance, fan support and heritage.
One forward step is buried near the end. The union and all four current clubs have agreed to meet later this year to start shaping how licensing under the new model will work.
The statement closes with an appeal for calm, warning that repeated cycles of infighting will only weaken a small rugby nation.
It names nobody, though the criticism has been loud closer to home. Swansea Council leader Rob Stewart called on chief executive Abi Tierney to resign. Swansea West MP Torsten Bell likened the union to a crook returning to the scene of their crime, and Scarlets managing director Jon Daniels demanded the union publish its evidence.
Removing the board is not straightforward. It would take resignations, or an extraordinary general meeting triggered by 10% of the WRU’s 282 member clubs followed by a vote. Swansea Council’s High Court challenge is still live, and the statement says nothing about the leaked recording of Tierney discussing a west Wales merger.
Related stories from Swansea Bay News
WRU: Cardiff and Dragons safe as Ospreys and Scarlets left fighting for one west Wales licence
The announcement that left the west with one licence for two teams.
WRU: Council leader calls on Abi Tierney to quit over leaked Ospreys-Scarlets merger tape
Rob Stewart’s resignation demand after the leaked recording emerged.
SCARLETS: Boss rules out Ospreys merger and demands WRU publish its evidence
Jon Daniels on the missing evidence behind the four-into-three plan.
OSPREYS: “Invest, build, compete, win”, the club lays out its case for the last west Wales licence
The Swansea club’s own answer to the licence fight.
Discover more from Swansea Bay News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
